In-House vs Outsourced Drafting: The Real Cost

Neither option is cheaper in general. An in-house drafter costs wages plus payroll taxes, benefits, software, hardware, training, management time, idle hours and turnover. Outsourcing costs the invoice plus your coordination and review time. Divide total in-house cost by productive drafting hours, then compare per project at slow, typical and peak volume. Steady volume favors in-house; uneven volume favors outsourcing or a hybrid.
- True in-house cost
- Total annual seat cost divided by productive drafting hours
- True outsourced cost
- Invoice plus internal handoff, coordination and review time
- Deciding factor
- How steady your drafting volume is through the year
Most shops compare an in-house drafter's salary with an outsourced invoice and stop there. That comparison misleads in both directions. It leaves out most of what an employee costs, and it leaves out the internal time an outsourced job still consumes. This guide lists every cost line on both sides and shows how to build the comparison with your own numbers. It quotes no salary or savings figures, because the answer depends on your region, your software, and above all your volume.
The spreadsheet most shops build
The usual version has two rows: annual drafter salary on one, and outsourced cost per project multiplied by last year's project count on the other.
The method has three flaws:
- Salary is not the cost of the seat. Payroll taxes, benefits, software, hardware, training, and supervision all sit on top of the wage.
- The outsourced invoice is not the cost of outsourcing. Someone in your shop still scopes the job, answers questions, and reviews the set.
- It compares a fixed cost with a variable one at a single volume. An employee costs the same in a slow month as in a busy one. A per-project service costs nothing when there is no work and more when there is a lot. The right answer changes with how much work you have and how evenly it arrives.
The fully loaded cost of a seat
Count every line below for one drafting seat over a year. Pull the figures from your own payroll and accounts payable records, not from an industry rule of thumb.
- Wages. Base pay plus overtime and bonuses. If you are budgeting a new hire and need a reference point, the US Bureau of Labor Statistics publishes Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics for drafters by state and metro area. There is no millwork-specific category, so treat the nearest occupation, such as architectural and civil drafters, as a starting point and check it against local job postings.
- Payroll taxes and insurance. The employer share of Social Security and Medicare, federal and state unemployment tax, and workers' compensation.
- Benefits. Health insurance contributions, retirement match, and paid vacation, holidays, and sick time. Paid time off matters twice: you pay for it, and it reduces the hours available for drafting.
- Software seats and maintenance. The engineering platform your shop runs, whether that is Microvellum, Cabinet Vision, AutoCAD, BricsCAD, or a combination, plus annual subscriptions or maintenance, add-on modules, and PDF markup tools.
- Hardware. A workstation capable of handling large drawing sets, monitors, and a replacement cycle. Spread the purchase price over the years you expect to keep it.
- Training and ramp-up. Vendor training, plus the weeks or months a new hire spends learning your library, construction methods, and title block standards before producing at full speed. Count the wages paid during that period and the senior time spent teaching.
- Management and review time. The hours your engineering lead or project manager spends assigning work, answering questions, and checking drawings, valued at that person's loaded rate.
- Idle capacity. Paid hours with no billable drafting to do. It rarely appears as a line in the books, but it raises the cost of every productive hour.
- Turnover. Recruiting costs, the vacancy period, and a second ramp-up. Estimate how often the seat has turned over in the past and spread that cost across the years.
- Rework. Drafting errors that reach the floor or the field cost material, machine time, and schedule. Count this for in-house and outsourced work alike, using your own history of remakes traced to drawings.
- Space and overhead. A desk, IT support, and the seat's share of general overhead, if your accounting allocates it.
For a view of how benefits and legally required costs sit on top of wages across the wider economy, the Bureau of Labor Statistics also publishes its Employer Costs for Employee Compensation series.
The full cost of outsourcing
The outsourced side needs the same treatment. Add these lines to the invoice total:
- Scoping and handoff. Time spent assembling the architectural set, specifications, and your standards for each job.
- Onboarding to your standards. The first few projects with any outside drafter take more of your time while they learn your construction methods, hardware preferences, and sheet layout. If you run Microvellum or Cabinet Vision, also count the effort to share and maintain your library or configuration.
- Coordination. Answering questions and relaying RFI responses. Time zone differences can stretch a one-hour question into a one-day delay, so factor in where the team works.
- Internal review. Someone in your shop should still check every set before it goes to the general contractor or to the CNC.
- Revisions outside the quoted scope. Ask how architect comments and design changes are priced, and include a realistic allowance based on how often your jobs change.
- Rework. As with in-house work, track remakes traced to drawing errors.
- Dependence and confidentiality. These are risks more than costs, but note them: what happens if the provider is at capacity when you need them, and whether a non-disclosure agreement covers your library and client documents.
Our guide on how to vet a Microvellum drafting service covers the questions that expose these costs before you sign.
Build the comparison with your own numbers
The steps below turn both lists into figures you can compare.
- Total the annual in-house cost. Add every line from the seat list. Call the result A.
- Calculate productive hours. Start with paid hours per year. Subtract vacation, holidays, sick time, training, and meetings. Then subtract the hours with no drafting work available. Call the result H.
- Find your in-house cost per productive hour. Divide A by H. This figure, not the hourly wage, is what an hour of in-house drafting costs you.
- Convert to a cost per project. Take three or four recently completed jobs of different sizes. Multiply the drafting hours each one took by your cost per productive hour.
- Get outsourced quotes for the same jobs. Ask for fixed prices against the actual drawing sets, so the quotes reflect real scope instead of a rate card.
- Add your internal time to each quote. Estimate the hours spent on handoff, coordination, and review for each job, multiply by the loaded rate of the person doing it, and add any revision allowance.
- Compare at three volumes. Run the totals for a slow month, a typical month, and your busiest month of the past two years. In-house cost stays roughly flat across the three. Outsourced cost rises and falls with the work.
The pattern to look for is the crossover. Above a certain steady volume, the in-house seat is fully used and its cost per project falls below the outsourced figure. Below that volume, idle hours push the in-house cost per project up. Where your shop sits relative to that point, and how far it swings during the year, is the answer to the question.
The throughput problem
Cost per project is only half of the decision. The other half is whether drawings are ready when the schedule needs them.
Millwork demand is uneven. Several awards can land in the same month, each with a submittal date, and a fixed staff has a fixed weekly output. When demand exceeds that output, the shop pays in other ways: overtime, late submittals that push fabrication, senior people pulled off estimating to draft, or bids declined because engineering is full. Put a number on these where you can.
The reverse is also true. A team sized for the peak is underused for the rest of the year, and step two of the worksheet shows exactly how much that costs.
When in-house wins
In-house drafting is the better choice for many shops. It usually wins when:
- Volume is steady enough to keep the seat busy. If productive hours are high all year, your cost per productive hour will be hard for any outside service to beat.
- Engineering and the floor are tightly coupled. A drafter who can walk to the CNC, see how a part machined, and fix the library the same afternoon is worth more than any hourly comparison shows, particularly in shops that depend on CNC-ready drawings.
- The work is repetitive and built on your library. Rollout programs and standard product lines reward accumulated knowledge that takes an outsider time to learn.
- You have a lead who can manage and review. Supervision and checking are already in place, so adding a seat adds little management cost.
- Turnaround needs are immediate. Same-day field revisions and constant small changes suit someone in the building.
- Confidentiality rules require it. Some clients restrict where their documents can go.
If most of these describe your shop, hire. Outsourcing wins in the opposite conditions: uneven volume, a seat you cannot keep full, difficulty recruiting drafters who know your software, or an occasional project type outside your team's experience.
The hybrid most shops land on
Many shops end up with both: an in-house core sized for the base load, and an outside partner for peaks, overflow, and specialty work.
A hybrid works when the outside partner is set up before the peak arrives:
- Run one or two ordinary projects through the partner during a quiet period so they learn your standards without schedule pressure.
- Give them your title block, layer standards, typical details, and a recent approved set as a model.
- Agree on who handles RFIs, how revisions are priced, and who does the final check.
- Keep one internal owner for every outsourced job.
When you collect quotes for the worksheet, ask each provider for a fixed price against a real drawing set. Millmetric, for example, returns a scoped fixed-price estimate within 24 to 48 business hours of receiving drawings, which gives you a firm figure for step five. Details of how overflow and ongoing work are handled are on our outsourced millwork drafting page, or you can send a drawing set for a quote to test against your in-house number.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to outsource millwork shop drawings or hire a drafter?
It depends on volume. A drafter whose time is fully used on steady work is usually hard to beat on cost per project. When work is uneven and the seat sits partly idle, the cost per productive hour rises and a per-project service can cost less. Calculate both with your own payroll, software and project records before deciding.
What costs should I include for an in-house millwork drafter?
Count wages, employer payroll taxes, workers' compensation, benefits and paid time off, software subscriptions or maintenance, a workstation, training and ramp-up time, management and review hours, idle capacity, turnover and recruiting, rework traced to drawing errors, and any allocated overhead. Then divide the annual total by the hours actually spent drafting to get a cost per productive hour.
Where can I find benchmark wage data for drafters?
The US Bureau of Labor Statistics publishes Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics by occupation, state and metro area. There is no millwork-specific drafter category, so use the closest occupation, such as architectural and civil drafters, as a starting point. Compare it with current local job postings and your own payroll, since millwork engineering skills can be priced differently.
When should a millwork shop keep drafting in-house?
Keep it in-house when volume is steady enough to keep the seat busy all year, when engineering needs daily contact with the CNC and the floor, when work is repetitive and built on your own library, when you already have a lead who can supervise and review, or when client confidentiality rules limit where documents can be sent.
Send the architectural drawings and specs. You get a fixed scope and price back within 24–48 business hours, before any drafting starts.
Get an Estimate →